Best Easter Squishmallows to Put in a Basket This Year

That little Easter basket starts looking a lot better the second you drop in one truly cute plush instead of five random fillers. That is exactly why Easter Squishmallows work so well. They feel festive, they photograph well, kids actually keep them, and they still hit that soft, collectible sweet spot that made Squishmallows huge in the first place. Squishmallows says the brand has grown to more than 3,000 styles since launching in 2017, which explains why seasonal hunting can turn into a full project fast.

For Easter, the strongest picks usually fall into a few lanes: classic bunnies, cheerful chicks, pastel spring characters, clip-ons for basket toppers, and a couple of more unusual designs for kids who already have a shelf full of basic rabbits.

Best Easter Squishmallows

1. Buttons the Blue Easter Bunny

If you want the safest all-around pick, start here. Retail listings describe Buttons as a blue Easter bunny, and that combination hits the holiday theme without feeling too generic. It is festive, soft-looking, and different enough from the usual pink-and-white bunny crowd to stand out in photos and on a bed.

Why it works:

• Strong Easter look right away
• Bunny design without being too plain
• Good gift for kids or collectors

2. Triston the Yellow Chick with Bucket Hat

This is one of the more playful Easter designs currently showing up in listings. Triston’s yellow chick design already fits spring, and the bucket hat detail makes it feel a bit more collectible than a standard chick plush. If the basket is for someone who likes characters with a little personality, this one is a smart choice.

Best for:

• Bright, cheerful baskets
• Younger kids
• Anyone who loves classic chick-and-bunny Easter colors

3. Aimee the Easter Chick

Aimee is one of the Easter Squishmallow names that keeps resurfacing in listings, and there is a reason for that. The chick design is instantly seasonal, and it reads as Easter even without a bunch of extra accessories. If you want something unmistakably spring-themed, Aimee is one of the strongest picks.

Best for:

• Traditional Easter baskets
• Kids who like chick and duck plush
• Shoppers who want a clear holiday match

4. Noe the Tie-Dye Sea Bunny

This is the “slightly different” Easter Squishmallow. Noe is not your classic basket bunny, and that is the appeal. Listings describe Noe as a tie-dye sea bunny, which makes it a fun option for kids who already have a few standard Easter plushies and want something with more color and a less obvious look.

Why I like it:

• Feels more unique than a plain bunny
• Works for Easter and year-round display
• Great for older kids who like unusual Squishmallows

5. Mini Buttons with Basket or Cupcake Details

If you are building a smaller basket, the mini versions can be a better move than forcing a larger plush into the center. Smaller listings for Buttons mention versions with basket or cupcake details, and those are great when you want the Squishmallow to feel like part of the basket instead of the whole present.

Best for:

• Basket toppers
• Budget-friendly Easter baskets
• Pairing with candy, books, or small toys

6. Holly the Purple Owl with Flower Pin

This is a nice pick if you want “spring” more than “obvious bunny.” Retail listings mention Holly as a purple owl with a flower pin, which gives it a softer floral Easter vibe without repeating the same rabbit-and-chick formula.

Best for:

• Kids who already own bunny plush
• Purple or pastel-themed baskets
• Spring gifts that can stay out after Easter

7. Pooh with Chocolate Bunny Easter Basket Design

Character crossovers can be a huge win, especially if the basket is for a Disney fan. A retail listing shows a Disney Pooh Easter version with a chocolate bunny basket theme, which makes this a fun pick for anyone who likes licensed Squishmallows more than the standard squad designs.

Best for:

• Disney-loving kids
• Character-themed baskets
• Gift-givers who want something a little different

8. Hello Kitty Easter Squishmallow

If you are shopping for a Sanrio fan, this one is an easy yes. Product listings show Easter Hello Kitty versions in Squishmallow form, and that combination is one of those gifts that does the work for you. It already feels collectible before it even goes in the basket.

Best for:

• Tweens
• Hello Kitty fans
• Baskets that lean cute and pastel

9. Easter Mystery Box Squishmallow

This is less about one character and more about the surprise factor. Mystery-box Easter Squishmallow listings are out there, and they make sense for kids who like the reveal almost as much as the plush itself. I would not make this my first pick for a very specific collector, but for surprise-loving kids, it is fun.

Best for:

• Kids who love surprises
• Sibling gift sets
• Last-minute shoppers who do not want to overthink the exact character

10. Bunnycorn Designs Like Legacy

A bunnycorn sits right in that sweet spot between Easter and fantasy plush. Listings for Legacy the Bunnycorn show why this style works so well. It still fits the holiday, but it does not feel boxed into one weekend. That makes it a great choice if you want the basket gift to stay relevant on the bed or shelf all year.

Best for:

• Unicorn-loving kids
• More whimsical baskets
• Gift-givers who want a less traditional Easter look

11. The Easter Squad 5-Inch or 8-Inch Multipack Route

If you are building more than one basket, the Easter Squad style bundles are often the smartest option. Product listings for 2025 Easter squads show small-format collections that can work for siblings, classroom gifts, or cousins without having to hunt down totally separate plushes one by one.

Best for:

• Multiple kids
• Matching baskets
• Budget control without losing the theme

The easiest way to choose one fast

• If you want the safest answer, pick a bunny.
• If you want the most traditional Easter look, pick a chick.
• If you want something that still feels special after Easter, pick a sea bunny or bunnycorn.
• If you are shopping for a collector, go for a character crossover or a seasonal variant with accessories.

A good Easter Squishmallow does not need to be the rarest one online. It just needs to look festive, fit the basket, and be the kind of plush that gets hugged or displayed long after the jelly beans are gone.